A Client Blames Your Software for Its Loss: A 10-Step Tech E&O Claim Playbook
A client says your software cost it money. What you do in the next few weeks largely decides how much your tech E&O policy pays. This playbook covers notice, evidence, admissions, counsel and the hammer clause.
First 72 Hours: Work Out Whether You Have a Claim or a Circumstance
Here's a hypothetical. A client's month-end billing run fails right after your release. Its CFO emails to say the outage cost $1.8 million in delayed revenue and that the company "reserves all rights." Your account team wants to calm things down. Your engineers want to start the postmortem. Hold both for an hour, because the tech E&O claim process has already started, even though nobody has filed a lawsuit.
Step 1: Classify what you've received. Most technology E&O wordings define a claim as a written demand for money or services, a lawsuit, an arbitration, or in some cases a regulatory proceeding. An email that names a dollar figure and asks for compensation is usually a claim. An angry message with no demand is usually a circumstance: something that could reasonably lead to a claim. The policy treats each differently, so get the label right.
Step 2: Pull the policy and read five clauses before anyone replies. Check the current policy and the one that just expired:
- The definition of claim and the notice deadline. Some policies say "as soon as practicable." Others give a fixed window after the policy period ends.
- The notice of circumstances provision.
- The no-admission and cooperation conditions.
- The consent to settle clause and any hammer wording.
- The retention, and whether defense costs erode the limit.
Give the file to one owner: the CFO, general counsel or risk manager. It shouldn't sit with the relationship manager who's trying to save the account.
Notify Early, and Notify Every Policy That Could Respond
Step 3: Send notice in writing. Tech E&O is almost always written on a claims-made, or claims-made-and-reported, basis. If notice arrives late, the insurer can deny cover outright. Some jurisdictions require an insurer to show it was prejudiced by late notice before denying. Many don't extend that protection to claims-made-and-reported policies, and the rules differ across the UK, EU member states, India, the Gulf states and individual US states. Don't rely on it.
A well-drafted notice of circumstances is the most valuable thing you can do this week. Once the insurer accepts it, a later claim arising from those facts generally attaches to the policy year in which you gave notice. That holds even if the claim arrives two years later and the renewal has a lower limit or a new exclusion. Insurers do reject vague notices, though. "We may face claims from customers" locks nothing in. Spell out:
- The client, the product or service, and the release or engagement involved
- The dates of the error and of the client's first complaint
- The alleged loss, using the client's own figure if it gave one
- The potential legal theories: breach of contract, negligence, breach of warranty
Send the notice to the address in the policy and copy your broker. Keep proof of delivery. Then go through the rest of the program. Notify the cyber policy if a security event or personal data is involved. Notify D&O if investors or directors could be drawn in. Notify every excess layer, because some excess carriers impose their own notice conditions.
Preserve the Record Before Engineers Clean It Up
Step 4: Issue a legal hold the same day. Cover deployment records, Git history, change tickets, CI/CD logs, monitoring data, incident chat channels, support tickets, release notes, and the contract, statement of work and SLA. Watch automatic deletion in particular. Many logging stacks rotate data within weeks. If the logs from the incident window disappear, you lose your best evidence of what actually broke, and you may face spoliation arguments as well.
Step 5: Move the root-cause analysis under counsel. Blameless postmortems are good engineering practice, and in litigation they often read like confessions: "we skipped regression tests to hit the date." Have outside counsel commission the investigation, and keep facts separate from opinions. Privilege protection depends heavily on jurisdiction. The US has attorney-client privilege and work product. The UK and many Commonwealth systems use legal advice privilege plus litigation privilege, which requires that litigation be the dominant purpose. Many EU civil-law systems give in-house lawyers' advice weaker protection, or none. Assume anything written outside a privileged channel will be disclosed.
Keep Fixing the Problem Without Admitting Liability
Step 6: Separate remediation from responsibility. Keep supporting the client. Walking away usually enlarges the damages, and some contracts require you to try to cure the problem. But nearly every policy forbids you to admit liability, agree a settlement, or take on costs without the insurer's consent. Breaching that condition can cost you cover for the whole claim.
| Safe to do | Avoid until the insurer consents |
|---|---|
| Acknowledge the issue and describe the technical fix | "This was entirely our fault" |
| Name one spokesperson for the account | Offering service credits or fee refunds as compensation |
| Mark settlement talks "without prejudice" or as settlement communications | Signing amendments that waive your liability cap |
| Log mitigation costs separately | Paying the client's consultants or overtime |
A label doesn't protect underlying facts in every jurisdiction, so the content of each message still matters. Expect that the cost of fixing your own product often isn't covered. Many wordings exclude rectification or "cost to redo," and some offer only a small mitigation-costs sublimit that requires prior consent.
Choose Defense Counsel and Test Your Contract Defenses
Step 7: Sort out who picks the lawyers, and who pays for them. Under duty-to-defend wordings, common in North America, the insurer appoints counsel. Many London-market and international policies work on a reimbursement basis instead: you choose counsel with the insurer's approval. Either way, defense costs usually sit inside the limit, so every dollar spent on lawyers reduces what's left for a settlement. Panel firms commonly charge somewhere in the low hundreds of dollars an hour up to roughly $650. Partners at non-panel firms can bill $800 to $1,500 or more. These are indicative 2026 ranges that vary by contract and country, so confirm with your carrier. If you insist on your own firm, get the approved rate in writing. Anything above it comes out of your budget.
Pick counsel on four points: experience with software disputes, standing in the forum named in your contract (courts or an arbitral seat), no conflicts with the client, and a written budget for the first 90 days.
Step 8: Read your contract as the client's lawyers will. In this phase of the tech E&O claim process, your best defenses are often already in the MSA. Look for a liability cap (commonly tied to 12 months of fees), an exclusion of lost profits and consequential loss, warranty disclaimers, and notice-and-cure provisions. In the billing example, a cap of 12 months' fees at $240,000 could shrink a $1.8 million demand dramatically. Enforceability varies. UK law applies a reasonableness test to some caps. Many jurisdictions won't enforce caps against gross negligence or willful misconduct, and some public-sector contracts override them. Counsel licensed in the governing jurisdiction should confirm where you stand.
How the Consent-to-Settle and Hammer Clauses Shift the Money
Step 9: Know your hammer before a settlement offer arrives. A consent to settle clause means the insurer can't settle without your agreement. That protects you when a payout would look like an admission to the rest of your customer base. The hammer clause is the price of that protection. If you refuse a settlement the insurer recommends and the client would accept, the insurer's liability is typically capped at that settlement figure plus defense costs incurred so far. Beyond that, you share the costs, in proportions the wording sets.
Hypothetical: the client will settle for $300,000. You refuse, go to trial, and lose a $700,000 judgment. Getting there costs another $250,000 in defense. Together, that's $650,000 above the rejected offer ($400,000 over the offer in damages plus $250,000 in defense). Hammer wordings differ on whether later defense costs fall inside the sharing formula, so check yours. The table assumes they do.
| Hammer type | Insurer pays of the $650,000 | You pay |
|---|---|---|
| Full hammer | $0 | $650,000 |
| Soft 50/50 | $325,000 | $325,000 |
| Soft 70/30 | $455,000 | $195,000 |
| Soft 80/20 | $520,000 | $130,000 |
| No hammer | $650,000 (within limits) | $0 |
UK professional indemnity wordings often include a KC clause (formerly the QC clause). Under it, you can't be forced to contest a claim unless a King's Counsel advises there's a reasonable prospect of success. Expect the reverse pressure too: an insurer may push to settle cheaply over a public allegation you'd rather fight. For most mid-size vendors, a 70/30 or 80/20 soft hammer is worth negotiating at renewal. A full hammer turns a refusal to settle into an uninsured bet.
Close the Claim Cleanly and Carry the Lessons Into Renewal
Step 10: Check the settlement paperwork, then fix the contracts. The settlement agreement needs:
- A full release covering affiliates and related claims
- A no-admission clause
- Confidentiality
- Written sign-off from every contributing insurer
You'll pay the retention. Indicative 2026 ranges run roughly $10,000 to $100,000 for smaller vendors and well into six or seven figures for large ones. Confirm against your own schedule.
At renewal, disclose the claim in full. Expect underwriters to ask about the root cause and the controls you've added since. A notice of circumstances accepted early generally keeps later claims from the same incident with the old policy year. Then tighten your templates: caps tied to fees, consequential-loss exclusions, and acceptance-testing obligations on the client.
The decision rule for next time: if you're unsure whether something counts as a claim, notify anyway. A precautionary notice rarely costs anything. Late notice can cost you the entire limit.
Quick answers
Does notifying my insurer about a circumstance increase my premium?
It can affect underwriting at renewal, but so does the incident whether you notify or not. An accepted notice ties any later claim to the current policy year. That usually works out better than having the claim land on a renewal that carries a new exclusion or a higher retention. Ask your broker how the notice will be presented to underwriters.
Can I give the client a service credit to keep the relationship?
Contractual SLA credits you already owe are usually fine. Credits or refunds offered as compensation for the alleged loss are different. Offered without the insurer's consent, they may count as voluntary payments the policy won't reimburse, and they could be read as an admission. Get written consent first.
Do defense costs reduce my tech E&O limit?
In most tech E&O and professional indemnity policies, yes. Defense costs sit inside the limit, so a long defense leaves less for a settlement or judgment. Some carriers sell defense-outside-limits options or additional defense sublimits, and pricing varies by market.
What happens if the claim arrives after my policy expires?
On a claims-made policy, a claim that arrives after expiry is generally covered only if you gave notice of the circumstances during the policy period, bought an extended reporting period, or the renewal picks it up. That's why early, specific notice matters. If you're switching carriers, make sure your notices are accepted before the old policy lapses.
Should I use the insurer's panel counsel or my own law firm?
Panel counsel is usually cheaper and already approved, which protects your limit. Your own firm can make sense if it knows your product, the governing law or the arbitral seat significantly better. Either way, agree rates and a budget in writing with the insurer before work starts.
Written by the Breachnodeops editorial team. Prices, features and rules change often - confirm details with the vendor or a licensed professional before you decide.